Check nearby libraries
Buy this book

The first book-length study of self-reference and paradox in law. From the author's preface:
Logical paradoxes in the strict sense produce statements like those of the Liar ("This very statement is false") that are false if true, and true if false. They resist rational solution or at least divide logicians for centuries of apparently irreconcilable wrangling. What happens when similar paradoxes arise in law?
That is a difficult question, but part of the answer is that paradoxes come and go without much notice and are dealt with without much ado. This fact makes the question important as well as difficult. How law copes with strict paradox sheds light on the nature of legal reasoning and rationality, the nature of legal practicality, and the sense in which law can be reasonable, even "wise", while being illogical in the technical sense.
I select one principal paradox —the paradox of self-amendment— and explore its variations in several Anglo-American jurisdictions and contexts, but mostly in American constitutional law. If a constitution has an amendment clause (a provision describing or prescribing how to amend that constitution), then can that clause be used to amend itself? The question may be widened to embrace the self-application of any legal rule that authorizes any legal change. Is self-amendment paradoxical? If so, can it be lawful? If so, can the logic of law be logical?
Check nearby libraries
Buy this book

Subjects
constitutional amendments, paradox, constitutional law, law, amendments, omnipotence, Self, MethodologyPeople
Peter Suber (1951 - )Places
United StatesEdition | Availability |
---|---|
1
The paradox of self-amendment: a study of logic, law, omnipotence, and change
1990, P. Lang, Lang Publishing, Incorporated, Peter
in English
0820412120 9780820412122
|
aaaa
|
Book Details
Edition Notes
Includes bibliographical references (p. [449]-478) and index.
Classifications
The Physical Object
Edition Identifiers
Work Identifiers
Source records
Scriblio MARC recordLibrary of Congress MARC record
amazon.com record
Better World Books record
Library of Congress MARC record
Harvard University record
Links outside Open Library
Community Reviews (0)
March 9, 2025 | Edited by MARC Bot | import existing book |
November 9, 2020 | Edited by MARC Bot | import existing book |
August 27, 2020 | Edited by ImportBot | import existing book |
April 4, 2019 | Edited by ImportBot | import existing book |
December 9, 2009 | Created by WorkBot | add works page |